Commercial Deed in Lieu of Foreclosure in California
The short answer
A deed in lieu is a deal, not a procedure: what the borrower and guarantor get back depends on the written agreement. Five points:
- It has to be a separate, later bargain. An agreement made at the time of the loan to hand over the property on default is void. (Civ. Code, § 2889; Hamud v. Hawthorne (1959) 52 Cal.2d 78, 84.) A deed given after default, in a fair and separate transaction, can be valid.
- Junior liens survive a deed in lieu. A trustee's sale generally cuts them off. That is why a lender may insist on foreclosing, or take the deed and then foreclose anyway. (Decon Group, Inc. v. Prudential Mortgage Capital Co., LLC (2014) 227 Cal.App.4th 665.)
- The debt is not automatically released. Code of Civil Procedure section 580d addresses a sale "under power of sale," and a deed in lieu is not one. Get the release in writing.
- A guaranty is a separate contract. Without a written release, it may survive the transfer.
- Taxes and bankruptcy can change the economics. Confirm transfer tax, including Los Angeles Measure ULA, before closing. And a deed in lieu can face a constructive fraudulent transfer challenge in a later bankruptcy that the U.S. Supreme Court has rejected for a properly conducted foreclosure sale.
On November 9, 2026, the Los Angeles Business Journal ran the headlines "Scoop: Lenders Set Foreclosure Auction for Radford Studio Center" and "Godfrey Hotel Hits Default." We know nothing about either deal beyond the headlines. For an owner behind on a building loan, the practical question is: should I just give the lender the keys?
What is a deed in lieu, and when will a court enforce it?
The basic trade
The Court of Appeal, quoting a California real estate treatise, has described a deed in lieu as a deed "given by the trustor to the beneficiary to avoid the inconveniences suffered on both sides by a formal foreclosure." (Decon Group, supra, 227 Cal.App.4th at p. 670.) Expect three documents: a grant deed, a deed-in-lieu agreement stating the consideration and releases, and an estoppel affidavit confirming facts the lender and its title insurer will rely on.
The anti-clogging rule
Civil Code section 2889 provides: "All contracts for the forfeiture of property subject to a lien, in satisfaction of the obligation secured thereby, and all contracts in restraint of the right of redemption from a lien, are void." That is why a lender cannot take a signed deed into escrow at closing and record it on default.
The California Supreme Court applied the rule in Hamud v. Hawthorne (1959) 52 Cal.2d 78, where a lender required the borrowers to deposit a quitclaim deed in escrow, to be recorded if the note went unpaid. The court held: "Where as here, however, the agreement purporting to waive or restrain redemption rights is made at the time of the loan, it is invalid." (Id. at p. 84.) Quoting Salter v. Ulrich (1943) 22 Cal.2d 263, 267, it explained that the right of redemption "may not be waived in advance," but "the mortgagor may subsequently deed the property to the mortgagee or may release or sell the right of redemption." (Hamud, at p. 84.)
The court described the valid later transfers as ones in which, after default, "the parties entered into a separate, distinct and subsequent contract," and, quoting Bastajian v. Brown (1943) 57 Cal.App.2d 910, 915, said such transfers "have been held valid by the courts where the transactions were fair and honest." (Hamud, at p. 83.)
So a deed in lieu is on firmer ground when it is negotiated after default in a separate agreement, for real consideration, as an outright transfer rather than more security. In Hamud, the trial court found the quitclaim was intended "to be a mortgage only," and the Supreme Court held the evidence supported that finding. (52 Cal.2d at pp. 82-83.)
The Hamud borrowers still lost on laches, because they waited nearly five years to sue. A borrower who believes a deed in lieu was really a disguised mortgage should not sit on the claim.
Why would a lender rather foreclose than take the deed?
Junior liens and mechanics liens
Decon Group quoted Miscione v. Barton Development Co. (1997) 52 Cal.App.4th 1320, 1326, for "the general rule is that foreclosure of a senior encumbrance terminates subordinate liens." By contrast, quoting the treatise, "[a] conveyance by a trustor through a deed in lieu of foreclosure (as opposed to a foreclosure deed) passes title to the transferee subject to all existing liens." (Decon Group, supra, 227 Cal.App.4th at p. 671.) A lender that takes a deed in lieu on a building with a second deed of trust, a judgment lien or a junior mechanics lien takes the building subject to them.
Mechanics liens need one more check. Under Civil Code section 8450, subdivision (a), a mechanics lien has priority over a deed of trust or other encumbrance that "attaches after commencement of the work of improvement," or that was unrecorded when work began and of which the claimant had no notice, subject to the exception in section 8452. If work began before the lender's deed of trust was recorded, a mechanics lien may be senior to the loan, and neither a deed in lieu nor a trustee's sale will remove it.
Merger, and the deed-then-foreclose structure
Traditionally, a lien merges into the title when the lienholder acquires the fee. On a deed in lieu, that would leave the lender owning the property subject to junior liens it could no longer foreclose out.
California courts ordinarily do not apply merger that way when there are junior liens of record. "Merger is always a question of intent when the question is as to whether a mortgage lien is merged in the fee, upon both being united in the same person." (Davis v. Randall (1897) 117 Cal. 12, 16-17, citation omitted, quoted in Decon Group, supra, 227 Cal.App.4th at p. 671.) In Decon Group, the borrower gave the senior lender a grant deed in lieu stating that the lender's interest "shall not merge" with its lien. The lender then foreclosed, and a junior mechanics lien claimant called the sale a sham. The Court of Appeal disagreed: "Under well-established California law, the senior beneficiary's lien and title ordinarily do not merge when a deed in lieu of foreclosure is given if there are junior lienholders of record." The later foreclosure "was therefore valid and eliminated all junior liens, including plaintiff's mechanic's lien." (227 Cal.App.4th at pp. 668–669.)
So expect an anti-merger clause, and do not assume a deed in lieu means no foreclosure. The lender may take the deed and still run a trustee's sale, or agree to a friendly foreclosure, a sale the borrower agrees not to contest, for the same kinds of consideration.
The estoppel affidavit speaks to the clogging, merger and bankruptcy risks a title insurer will weigh. For the borrower, it is a set of signed admissions: the transfer is voluntary, the consideration is fair, the deed is not security. Do not sign one that is not true.
Does a deed in lieu wipe out the debt and my personal guaranty?
The borrower's debt
Not automatically. Code of Civil Procedure section 580d, subdivision (a), bars a deficiency where the property "has been sold by the mortgagee or trustee under power of sale contained in the mortgage or deed of trust." A deed in lieu is a conveyance by the borrower, not a sale under the power of sale. On the statute's text, section 580d does not reach it, and we have not found a published California decision holding that a deed in lieu, by itself, bars a deficiency.
The agreement therefore controls. Do not deliver a deed without a written release of the note, or at least a covenant not to sue, covering every amount the lender could claim. We also have not found a published decision applying the one-action rule of section 726, subdivision (a), to a lender that takes a deed in lieu and then sues for the balance. In a different setting, a Court of Appeal applying section 726 held that a lender who released its real property security without a co-maker's consent lost the right to collect the note from that co-maker (Pacific Valley Bank v. Schwenke (1987) 189 Cal.App.3d 134, 146), so every obligor should sign the deal. Settle the point on paper.
If the lender takes the deed and then completes a trustee's sale, as in Decon Group, section 580d, subdivision (a), applies to the note by its terms. Our article on judicial versus non-judicial foreclosure explains the anti-deficiency statutes.
The guarantor
A deed-in-lieu agreement with the borrowing entity does not release a personal guaranty unless it says so. Section 580d, subdivision (b), provides that the bar on a deficiency "does not affect the liability that a guarantor, pledgor, or other surety might otherwise have with respect to the deficiency." Civil Code section 2856, subdivision (a)(3), lets a guarantor waive "[a]ny rights or defenses the guarantor or other surety may have because the principal's note or other obligation is secured by real property or an estate for years," and a commercial guaranty may well contain that waiver.
The deed in lieu is the guarantor's moment of leverage. Negotiate an express release naming each guarantor and covering any payment guaranty, carve-out guaranty and environmental indemnity. Watch for a springback clause reviving the release if the transfer is later set aside in bankruptcy. And on a nonrecourse loan with a carve-out guaranty, make sure nothing done to complete the deal triggers recourse.
Our article on a personal guaranty after a commercial loan default covers guaranty waivers and defenses in detail.
Will a deed in lieu trigger transfer tax, and can bankruptcy undo it?
The state documentary transfer tax
Revenue and Taxation Code section 11911 authorizes a county, and a city within a county that has imposed the tax, to impose a documentary transfer tax by ordinance. Section 11926 provides that "Any tax imposed pursuant to this part shall not apply with respect to any deed, instrument, or writing to a beneficiary or mortgagee, which is taken from the mortgagor or trustor as a result of or in lieu of foreclosure", but the tax "shall apply to the extent that the consideration exceeds the unpaid debt, including accrued interest and cost of foreclosure." The consideration, the unpaid debt and the grantee's status as beneficiary or mortgagee must be noted on the deed or stated in an affidavit or declaration under penalty of perjury.
Note the limits: the exemption covers a deed "to a beneficiary or mortgagee," so a deed to a lender's designee needs separate review, and cash paid to the borrower can count as consideration above the debt.
Los Angeles Measure ULA
Within the City of Los Angeles, Measure ULA adds a transfer tax on conveyances above thresholds the City adjusts each year. The City's Office of Finance FAQ states that the ULA tax does not apply to "All other transactions which are exempt from the base Real Property Transfer Tax per local, state, or federal laws and regulations," and that the ULA tax is calculated on gross value, including liens remaining on the property.
The City's ordinance lists its own exemptions, and a deed in lieu is not among them (L.A. Mun. Code, §§ 21.9.4–21.9.16). But the ordinance says it is adopted under Part 6.7 of the Revenue and Taxation Code, where section 11926 sits, and directs the County Recorder to administer it "in conformity with the provisions of Part 6.7" (§§ 21.9.1, 21.9.9). We found no City rule addressing deeds in lieu by name, and commentators have cautioned that the FAQ is not clear and may not have the force of law. Before closing on a City of Los Angeles property, confirm the treatment in writing with the Office of Finance and the County Recorder.
Bankruptcy: fraudulent transfer and preference risk
- Fraudulent transfer. Under 11 U.S.C. section 548, subdivision (a)(1), a trustee may avoid a transfer made "on or within 2 years before the date of the filing of the petition" if, among other grounds, the debtor "received less than a reasonably equivalent value in exchange" and was insolvent or became insolvent as a result. A transfer is treated as made when it is perfected against a bona fide purchaser (§ 548(d)(1)), which for a deed generally means recording.
- The foreclosure rule may not help. In BFP v. Resolution Trust Corp. (1994) 511 U.S. 531, 545, the Supreme Court held that reasonably equivalent value for foreclosed real property is the price received at the foreclosure sale, so long as the state's foreclosure law was followed. The Court added: "We emphasize that our opinion today covers only mortgage foreclosures of real estate." (Id. at p. 537, fn. 3.) A negotiated deed in lieu is not a foreclosure sale. If the property is worth more than the debt released, a trustee may argue the borrower did not receive reasonably equivalent value.
- Preference. Under 11 U.S.C. section 547, subdivision (b), a trustee may avoid a transfer to a creditor for an antecedent debt, made while the debtor was insolvent, within 90 days before the petition (or up to one year for an insider), that lets the creditor receive more than it would in a Chapter 7 liquidation.
These look-back periods run backward from the date a bankruptcy petition is filed. A bankruptcy trustee may also use state voidable transfer law under 11 U.S.C. section 544(b), and California's Uniform Voidable Transactions Act allows a constructive fraudulent transfer claim within four years after the transfer (Civ. Code, § 3439.09, subd. (b)), so do not treat the risk as closed when the two-year federal period ends. That is one reason a lender may prefer a foreclosure sale, and why a guarantor should read the springback clause.
Timing, cash for keys and the trustee's sale
Negotiating a deed in lieu does not stop a scheduled trustee's sale. Unless the sale is actually postponed, it can go forward while the parties are talking, and a lender may keep the foreclosure running as leverage. Civil Code section 2924g requires postponement on mutual agreement, oral or written, so get it in writing and confirm the new date with the trustee. Our companion article on stopping a California trustee's sale covers the options.
Cash for keys means consideration to the borrower for an orderly handover: leases, deposits, service contracts, records, keys and cooperation with tenants. If the lender is collecting rents or has a receiver in place, the handover terms should fit that arrangement; see our article on assignment of rents and receivers.
What to do
- Pull the title report. List every lien and lease, and check mechanics lien priority against the deed of trust's recording date.
- Read the loan documents and every guaranty for recourse, carve-out triggers and waivers.
- Get any sale postponement in writing. Talks do not stop the clock.
- Negotiate the releases before the deed. Release the note, every guarantor and the indemnities. Do not rely on section 580d.
- Read the anti-merger clause and estoppel affidavit line by line.
- Confirm transfer tax, including the section 11926 recitals and City of Los Angeles treatment, before recording.
- Assess bankruptcy exposure by comparing value with the debt released, and calendar the federal and state look-back periods from recording.
- Talk to a tax adviser before signing. Giving up property for a release of debt can have tax consequences for the borrower and its owners.
A deed in lieu is a contract, and disputes over one are contract and title disputes. Our contract disputes practice handles workout and guaranty disputes, and our quiet title and partition practice handles title questions after a contested transfer.
Common questions
What is a deed in lieu of foreclosure in California?
It is a deed from a borrower to a lender, given after a loan default to avoid a foreclosure sale, on terms set by a separate written agreement. A promise made when the loan was made to hand over the property on default is void under Civil Code section 2889, but a later, separate and fair transaction can be valid.
Does a deed in lieu release me from the rest of the loan?
Not automatically. The anti-deficiency rule in Code of Civil Procedure section 580d applies when the property is sold under the power of sale in the deed of trust, and a deed in lieu is not that kind of sale. We have not found a published California decision holding that a deed in lieu by itself bars a deficiency, so the release should be written into the deed-in-lieu agreement.
Does a deed in lieu release my personal guaranty?
Not unless the agreement says so. A guaranty is a separate contract, Code of Civil Procedure section 580d states that its bar on a deficiency does not affect the liability a guarantor might otherwise have, and Civil Code section 2856 allows guarantors to waive real-property defenses. A guarantor should seek an express written release.
Why would a lender refuse a deed in lieu and foreclose instead?
A deed in lieu passes title subject to existing liens, while a trustee's sale generally cuts off liens junior to the foreclosed deed of trust. A lender facing junior liens may insist on a sale, or take the deed with an anti-merger clause and then foreclose.
Is a deed in lieu subject to the Los Angeles mansion tax (Measure ULA)?
The City of Los Angeles says transactions exempt from its base transfer tax under local, state or federal law are also exempt from Measure ULA, but we could not confirm an express deed-in-lieu exemption from the City's base tax, so confirm the treatment with the City before recording.
This article is general information about California law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes and case law change, and how they apply depends on the specific facts. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes. Robert B. Mobasseri, State Bar No. 193193, ROMO Law Group, Encino, California.