Can't Get Home Insurance in Escrow? California Buyer Rights
The short answer
You are in escrow on a California home. Then the insurance quotes come back: one carrier declines, another is not writing in your ZIP code, and the only offer is a California FAIR Plan policy at a premium that breaks your budget. Can you walk away and get your deposit back?
It depends on what your purchase contract says and whether you have already removed the contingency that covers insurance.
The California Association of REALTORS (C.A.R.) Residential Purchase Agreement now treats insurance as its own contingency. In the December 2024 revision we reviewed (RPA Revised 12/24), the contract is contingent "upon Buyer's assessment of the availability and approval of the cost for any insurance policy desired under this Agreement," and the default time to remove that contingency is 17 calendar days after acceptance. A buyer who cancels in writing under it, in good faith and before removing it, is generally entitled to the deposit back, less certain escrow fees.
Once the insurance contingency is removed, the picture changes. The same form says failure to obtain insurance "may justify cancellation based on the Insurance contingency but not the loan contingency." A buyer who then cannot close because of insurance may be in breach. If both sides initialed the liquidated damages clause, what the seller may keep is governed by that clause and the statutory limits discussed below.
C.A.R. has revised the RPA since December 2024. Check the revision date printed at the bottom of each page of your contract before relying on anything below.
Can a buyer cancel if they can't get homeowners insurance?
The market behind the problem
On its Sustainable Insurance Strategy page (updated November 20, 2026), the California Department of Insurance says that under the strategy insurers "will be required to write more policies in wildfire-distressed areas and reverse the growth of the FAIR Plan, California's 'last resort' insurance plan." The FAIR Plan reports that, as of September 2026, it had 698,307 dwelling and commercial policies in force, a 157 percent increase since September 2022.
The FAIR Plan is a statutory pool. Insurance Code section 10091(a) describes it as an association of insurers formed "to assist persons in securing basic property insurance," and section 10091(c)(1) defines basic property insurance by reference to the standard fire policy, extended coverage, and vandalism and malicious mischief, plus other coverages added with the Insurance Commissioner's approval. That can be narrower than a homeowners package policy, which is one reason a FAIR Plan quote can be available and still unacceptable to a buyer.
The insurance contingency in the current RPA
C.A.R. released revised forms on June 25, 2024, adding a separate buyer contingency for insurance availability and cost. In the 12/24 revision we reviewed:
- Paragraph 8D makes the agreement contingent "upon Buyer's assessment of the availability and approval of the cost for any insurance policy desired under this Agreement."
- Paragraph 3L(4) sets the removal deadline at 17 (or a different agreed number of) Days after Acceptance.
- Paragraph 12B(2) takes insurance out of the general investigation contingency: "Buyer Investigations do not include, among other things, an assessment of the availability and cost of general homeowner's insurance, flood insurance, and fire insurance."
The contingency turns on the buyer's own assessment and approval of cost, so a buyer who finds only a FAIR Plan policy at a price they will not pay has a contractual basis to cancel while the contingency is in effect. The right is not unlimited. The form lets the buyer cancel by "good faith exercise of any Buyer contingency included in paragraph 8 ... so long as that contingency has not already been removed in writing." A buyer who invokes insurance as cover for a different reason invites a fight about good faith.
If your contract is an older form
Before the June 2024 revision, insurance sat inside the general investigation contingency. Describing the December 2022 RPA, attorney David Hamerslough wrote in January 2023 that the form's Buyer Investigations "include but are not limited to an investigation of the availability and cost of general homeowners' insurance, flood insurance, and fire insurance." On that kind of form, insurance cancellation rights generally travel with the investigation contingency and end when it is removed.
How the clock works
The RPA counts deadlines in calendar days. Under the 12/24 form's counting rules, the day of acceptance is Day 0, the next calendar day is Day 1, and the last day for performance ends at 11:59 pm. If that last day falls on a Saturday, Sunday, or legal holiday, the form allows performance on the next day that is not. The deadline is not the end of the buyer's rights. Under the 12/24 form, even after the contingency period expires, and before the seller cancels, the buyer may still remove the contingency or cancel based on it. To cancel, the seller must first deliver a Notice to Buyer to Perform, which must be in writing, signed, and give the buyer at least 2 Days after delivery to act; it cannot be delivered earlier than 2 Days before the scheduled deadline. If the seller then cancels, the form requires the seller to authorize return of the buyer's deposit, except for fees incurred by the buyer.
Does the loan contingency cover a failed insurance search?
A mortgage lender may require hazard insurance before funding, so the loan contingency looks like a backstop. C.A.R.'s position is that it is not.
Paragraph 8A(2) of the 12/24 RPA says: "Buyer's ability to obtain insurance for the Property, including fire insurance, is part of Buyer's Insurance contingency. Failure of Buyer to obtain insurance may justify cancellation based on the Insurance contingency but not the loan contingency."
C.A.R.'s January 8, 2025 Quick Guide on fire insurance takes the same view: where the lender refuses to lend because the buyer has not bought a policy because of its cost or coverage, "the lender's failure to loan would be due to the buyer's affirmative decision and would not justify exercise of the loan contingency." C.A.R.'s summary of its June 2026 forms release lists, among the RPA changes: "Clarified that loan contingency cannot be used if buyer is unable to obtain insurance."
We have not found a published California appellate decision deciding whether a residential loan contingency can be used when the only obstacle to funding is insurance. Under contract language like the RPA's, the argument is uphill. Under a different form, the answer depends on that form's words.
What removing contingencies does
Under the 12/24 RPA, a buyer who removes a contingency is "conclusively" deemed to have completed the related investigations, "elected to proceed with the transaction," and assumed responsibility for, among other things, "the inability to obtain financing."
In Urban Sunrise, LLC v. Vogt (2026) 122 Cal.App.5th 1261, a published Third District Court of Appeal opinion, a commercial buyer of five properties agreed, in exchange for escrow extensions, to remove its remaining contingencies and release earnest money and additional deposits to the sellers as nonrefundable. The transactions "were unsuccessful because the buyer ... did not secure loans for the properties due to the cost of fire insurance," and the buyer "forfeited over $1.1 million to the sellers." (Id. at p. 1265.) It then sued the broker and agent, who had acted as dual agents for both the buyer and the sellers. The trial court granted summary judgment for the agents on the buyer's claims, and the Court of Appeal affirmed. It concluded the buyer "had the information necessary to make a well-informed decision regarding the purchase of the properties" given the insurance issues, and had "contractually agreed to assume the responsibility for investigating the availability and cost of insurance." (Id. at pp. 1280–1281.)
Urban Sunrise is a commercial broker-duty case with express nonrefundable releases, but the lesson carries over: resolve insurance before the contingency comes off.
What happens to the deposit, and what are the seller's rights?
If the buyer cancels properly
When either party cancels under rights duly exercised under the contract, the 12/24 RPA requires both to sign mutual instructions to cancel escrow and release the deposit to the party entitled to it, less escrow fees and costs charged to that party. Release requires "mutual Signed release instructions from the Parties, judicial decision or arbitration award." C.A.R.'s June 2026 summary also lists a revision that "Clarified that deposit should be returned to buyer, even after DCE, if buyer is trying to satisfy a contingency." (DCE is the Demand to Close Escrow form.)
If the seller will not sign
Civil Code section 1057.3 is the pressure point. For a home of one to four units, at least one of which the buyer is to occupy, once the purchase has not closed by the contract's close-of-escrow date, a party who fails to sign the documents escrow needs to release the funds "within 30 days following a written demand for the return of funds deposited in escrow by the other party" is liable for the funds not held in good faith, treble damages of not less than $100 or more than $1,000, and reasonable attorney's fees. There is no liability if the funds are withheld to resolve a good faith dispute, and the party seeking the deposit must prove there was none. Our article on whether a seller can keep the deposit walks through section 1057.3 in detail.
Where a buyer cancelled on time and in good faith under a live insurance contingency, a seller's claim to a good faith dispute may be weak.
If the buyer removed the contingency and then cannot close
Before cancelling for failure to close, the 12/24 RPA requires a Demand to Close Escrow giving the other party at least 3 Days after delivery to close. If the buyer still does not close and both parties initialed the liquidated damages clause, that clause governs what the seller may keep. In the 12/24 form, where the property is a dwelling with no more than four units, one of which the buyer intends to occupy, the amount the seller retains "shall be no more than 3% of the purchase price," with any excess returned to the buyer.
That term tracks Civil Code section 1675: for a dwelling of up to four units that the buyer intends to occupy, liquidated damages actually paid of up to 3 percent of the price are valid unless the buyer proves them unreasonable, and an amount above 3 percent is invalid unless the seller proves it reasonable. Section 1677 requires the clause to be separately signed or initialed by each party and, in a printed contract, set in at least 10-point bold type or 8-point bold red print. Without a valid clause, the seller must prove actual damages.
A seller need not extend escrow while a buyer keeps shopping for insurance, but if the parties agree to one, put it in a signed amendment; informal messages breed disputes (see you said yes by text, you may not have a deal).
What does the seller have to disclose about insurance?
Claims history and non-renewals
We have not found a California statute that requires a home seller to disclose prior insurance claims, a CLUE report, or a non-renewal notice as such. The duty, where it exists, comes from the contract and the common law.
Paragraph 11O of the 12/24 RPA requires the seller to disclose known material facts and defects, "including, but not limited to, known insurance claims within the past five years, or provide Buyer with permission to contact insurer to get such information (C.A.R. Form ARC)."
In Lingsch v. Savage (1963) 213 Cal.App.2d 729, 735, the Court of Appeal stated: "It is now settled in California that where the seller knows of facts materially affecting the value or desirability of the property which are known or accessible only to him and also knows that such facts are not known to, or within the reach of the diligent attention and observation of the buyer, the seller is under a duty to disclose them to the buyer." Whether a particular claim or non-renewal is material depends on the facts. A seller who knows the home is hard to insure because of an unrepaired condition an insurer flagged stands differently from a seller whose carrier simply left the market.
The disclosure duties in the article beginning at Civil Code section 1102 cannot be bargained away. Civil Code section 1102(c) provides: "Any waiver of the requirements of this article is void as against public policy." An "as is" clause does not change that.
Fire hazard disclosures that bear on insurability
- Very high fire hazard severity zone. Government Code section 51183.5 requires a transferor of property in a very high fire hazard severity zone to disclose that fact when the transferor or agent has actual knowledge or the required map and notice have been provided, generally on the Natural Hazard Disclosure Statement.
- State responsibility area. Public Resources Code section 4136 requires a similar disclosure for property in a state responsibility area, a wildland area that may contain substantial forest fire risks.
- Fire hardening notice. Civil Code section 1102.6f applies to homes built before January 1, 2010 in a high or very high fire hazard severity zone. The seller must give a statutory fire-hardening notice and disclose which listed vulnerable features the seller knows of. On or after July 1, 2025, the notice must also list low-cost retrofits developed under Government Code section 51189 and disclose which, if any, were completed while the seller owned the property.
- Defensible space documentation. Under Civil Code section 1102.19, a seller of property in a high or very high fire hazard severity zone must provide documentation of compliance with Public Resources Code section 4291 or a local vegetation management ordinance, as the local framework provides. If the seller has not obtained it, the parties must sign a written agreement under which the buyer agrees to obtain it.
Recent additions, including the electrical inspection notice in Civil Code section 1102.6i, are covered in our 2026 disclosure requirements article.
Under Civil Code section 1102.3, if a disclosure or material amendment required by that article is delivered after the offer is executed, the buyer has three days after delivery in person, or five days after delivery by mail or electronic record, to terminate by written notice. That right is separate from any contract contingency.
What to do
If you are the buyer:
- Shop insurance before you offer. C.A.R.'s own guidance advises buyers to investigate the cost and availability of fire insurance before making an offer.
- Keep the insurance contingency. Do not waive it with the offer, and consider negotiating more than 17 days if the property is in a fire zone.
- Count calendar days from acceptance and keep written quotes and declinations.
- Cancel in writing before you remove the contingency, and do not remove it until a policy you accept is bound or committed.
- Send a written demand for the deposit if the seller will not sign release instructions. Where section 1057.3 applies and the scheduled close of escrow has passed, that demand starts its 30-day clock.
If you are the seller:
- Disclose what you know. Gather claims for the past five years or sign the authorization the contract calls for, and complete fire hazard and defensible space documents early.
- Follow the contract's notice procedure. Cancelling without a valid Notice to Buyer to Perform or Demand to Close Escrow can cost you the stronger position.
- Do not hold a deposit you are not entitled to. Where section 1057.3 applies, refusing to sign after a timely contingency cancellation risks its penalties.
Insurance-driven escrow failures can become deposit disputes, disclosure claims, or, where a seller balks instead, a specific performance case. Our purchase and sale disputes practice represents buyers and sellers in these cases.
Common questions
Can I cancel a California home purchase if I cannot get homeowners insurance?
Possibly. Under the 12/24 C.A.R. purchase agreement, the contract is contingent on the buyer's assessment of insurance availability and approval of its cost, with a default of 17 calendar days after acceptance to remove that contingency, and the buyer can still cancel after that period until the seller cancels following a Notice to Buyer to Perform. A buyer who cancels in writing, in good faith, before removing it is generally entitled to the deposit back less certain fees. Older forms and custom contracts may treat insurance differently, so check the form and its revision date.
Can I use the loan contingency if my lender will not fund without insurance?
Under the 12/24 C.A.R. form, likely not. The form says failure to obtain insurance may justify cancellation under the insurance contingency but not the loan contingency, and C.A.R. guidance takes the same position. Other contract language may lead to a different answer.
Does a California seller have to disclose insurance claims or a non-renewal?
We have not found a statute that requires it as such. The 12/24 C.A.R. form requires the seller to disclose known insurance claims within the past five years or authorize the buyer to get that information from the insurer, and California common law requires a seller to disclose known facts materially affecting value or desirability that the buyer cannot reasonably discover.
What happens to my deposit if I removed contingencies and then cannot get insurance?
You may be in breach. If both parties initialed the liquidated damages clause, the seller may be entitled to keep the deposit up to the amount the contract allows. Under the 12/24 C.A.R. form, for a home of one to four units the buyer intended to occupy, that is no more than 3 percent of the price, and Civil Code section 1675 treats up to 3 percent as valid unless the buyer proves it unreasonable. Without a valid clause, the seller must prove actual damages.
This article is general information about California law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Statutes and case law change, and how they apply depends on the specific facts. Attorney advertising. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcomes. Robert B. Mobasseri, State Bar No. 193193, ROMO Law Group, Encino, California.